Give us your paper requirements, choose a writer and well deliver the highest-quality essay! Get Annual Plans at a discount when you buy 2 or more! Answers: 1 Get Iba pang mga katanungan: English. Jig and her lover are clearly on completely different wavelengths. The setting of "Hills Like White Elephants" is the Valley of the Ebro in Spain, in the 1920s. Catherine Sustana, Ph.D., is a fiction writer and a former professor of English at Hawaii Pacific University. (one code per order). In this gender framework, the man makes the decisions and the female complies. Welcome to " Hills Like White Elephants ." This little story is notorious for packing an outsized punch: it's read in countless classrooms in countless universities and high schools, contained in countless "Best Short Stories Ever"-type anthologies, and prompts countless readers to doubt the following truths universally acknowledged: At the heart of "Hills Like White Elephants" is Hemingway's examination of the man and girl 's deeply flawed relationship, a relationship that champions "freedom" at the cost of honesty, respect, and commitment. However, as the story illustrates, such a power dynamic is fundamentally flawed and destructive. But I dont want you to do it if you dont really want to. Hemingways couple pretends to be conflicted regarding the effects a child will have on an otherwise loving, mutually-supportive relationship, but the reality appears far different. Are there any metaphors in the story "Hills Like White Elephants" by Ernest Hemingway? Purchasing Aside from 'the woman' who brings the couple drinks and is only seen a few times, the American and the girl are the only characters who ever say anything. He always orders the drinks, and they reference him wanting to try absinthe in the past. The man sees the baby primarily as a limit to his freedom, hence his insistence that they have the procedure. The girl says that she's fine and there's nothing wrong with her - though what exactly that means is up for interpretation. I wouldn't have you do it if you didn't want to," he is not convincing. The exact topic of their conversation isn't revealed, but from context clues and symbols readers can deduce that Jig is pregnant, and the man is trying to convince her to have an abortion. But I dont want anybody but you. Refine any search. for a group? Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. She alternates between wanting to talk about the operation and wanting to avoid the topic altogether. The man. The Girl (Jig) Character Timeline in Hills Like White Elephants The timeline below shows where the character The Girl (Jig) appears in Hills Like White Elephants. It is apparent that there is significant tension between the two, and the point of contention appears to be that he wants her to have an abortion, while she wants to keep her baby. Just like we were before.What makes you think so? Thats the only thing that bothers us. 10th Grade English: Homework Help Resource, American Prose for 10th Grade: Homework Help, Hills Like White Elephants: Theme, Symbolism & Literary Analysis, Psychological Research & Experimental Design, All Teacher Certification Test Prep Courses. At the end of Hills Like White Elephants, the man comes back from checking on the train and having a drink. In part, this new appreciation for the story lies in Hemingway's use of dialogue to convey the "meaning" of the story that is, there is no description, no narration, no identification of character or intent. They have clearly been in a romantic and sexual relationship, which has led to Jig being pregnant. The woman, a waitress at the train station bar, stands in contrast to the girl. Instead, Hemingway so removes himself from them and their actions that it seems as though he himself knows little about them. When the girl comments that the hills look like white elephants and the man says he's never seen one, she answers, "No, you wouldn't have." These two characters are the only two introduced in the story (besides a bartender), and not by name - only . The man and the girl he calls Jig are lovers. The woman serving drinks to the American man and the girl. The author uses a lot of rhetorical devices to convey his message but mostly use imagery and symbolism. I wouldnt have you do it if you didnt want to. Removing #book# William Faulkner Biography & Books | Who was William Faulkner? The geography of the real-life valley is notable as well: one side is dry and barren (the hills like white elephants), and the other is lush and green. "Hills Like White Elephants," written by Ernest Hemingway in 1927, is a short story that describes a seemingly casual, but slightly tense, conversation between a couple at a train station in the Ebro Valley in Spain. In this sense, the man and girl represent stereotypes of male and female roles: the male as active and the female as passive. The full pasts of the characters are never revealed, but there are hints in their conversations and in their luggage. His pushiness ultimately seems to solidify her opinion against him as the story comes to a close. I was being amused. In the story, Hemingway refers to the Ebro River and to the bare, sterile-looking mountains on one side of the train station and to the fertile plains on the other side of the train station. PDF downloads of all 1699 LitCharts literature guides, and of every new one we publish. Dont have an account? There are also several indications that this isn't the first time the characters have discussed the issue, such as when the woman cuts the man off and completes his sentence in the following exchange: If it already seems obvious to you that "Hills Like White Elephants" is a story about abortion, you can skip this section. It isn't surprising, then, that there is so much tension between them. Hills Like White Elephants and Other Hemingway Stories, Hills Like White Elephants by Ernest Hemingway | Theme, Symbolism & Analysis, Barn Burning by William Faulkner | Summary & Analysis, Babylon Revisited by F. Scott Fitzgerald | Summary, Characters & Analysis, Miss Brill by Katherine Mansfield | Themes & Analysis, The Chrysanthemums by John Steinbeck | Symbolism, Themes & Analysis. From his earlier statements, it is obvious that he does not want the responsibility that a child would entail; seemingly, he strongly wants her to have this abortion and definitely seems to be very unresponsive to the girl's feelings. The only surprise is that they ever got together in the first place. Wed love to have you back! Neither is ever given a formal name - perhaps an attempt by Hemingway to make the characters more relatable to his readers. Latest answer posted October 17, 2020 at 10:39:34 AM. By entering your email address you agree to receive emails from SparkNotes and verify that you are over the age of 13. lessons in math, English, science, history, and more. The point of contention between them is that the man wants Jig to have an abortion, and Jig seems hesitant. on 2-49 accounts, Save 30% These lovers are like ships that pass in the night, as distant from each other as if they'd never even met. But underneath the surface of "Hills Like White Elephants" there are hidden meanings, themes, and motives for each character. He claims that she "know[s] how [he] get[s]." A man and a young woman sit in a Spanish train station, drinking, talking, and appreciating the countryside scenery across the valley of the Ebro. Its like a teacher waved a magic wand and did the work for me. Throughout this dialogue, the girl's crumbling realization that she is not truly loved is a strong undercurrent that creates tension and suppressed fear. She also realizes that she is not loved, at least not unconditionally. In an exchange toward the end of the story, the woman seeks solace in the liberating consequence of the abortion only to have the man dampen those expectations despite his advocacy of her having the abortion. She soon comes to realize her own desires and struggles to assert herself for the . The American, still pretending to be supportive, continues to push the issue of abortion until the girl begs him to stop talking. Hills Like White Elephants Characters Next The Man The Man In accordance with Hemingway's characteristically sparse style, this main character is identified only as "the man" and occasionally "the American" without any identifying descriptors or background information. Please wait while we process your payment. This short story is set at a lonely railway station along the Ebro River that runs through northeastern Spain, where Ernest Hemingway spent a considerable amount of time during the early 20th century. Jig's focus is on the outside world, which is somewhat ironic given that she is carrying her lover's baby, which one would've thought would be her main preoccupation. The girl says the hills across the valley look like white elephants, and she and the man argue briefly. I wouldnt have you do it if you didnt want to. for a customized plan. read analysis of The Woman (the Waitress). Renew your subscription to regain access to all of our exclusive, ad-free study tools. I feel fine. This final act of concealment and self-suppression suggests that this relationship, so representative of the traditional dynamic between men and women at the time,will remain stalled in its present unhealthy stateuntil it likely falls apart completely. An American man and a girl are sitting at an outdoor caf in a Spanish train station, waiting for a fast, non-stop train coming from Barcelona that will take them to Madrid, where the girl will have an abortion. The girl says the hills look like white elephants for a couple reasons. Find related themes, quotes, symbols, characters, and more. Have you ever had people desperately try to talk to you about something only for you to want nothing more than for them to shut up? It's not difficult to understand, though, with careful reading and an understanding of Hemingway's methods and hints. English, 28.10.2019 17:29, . Summary and Analysis She is pregnant, carrying the American's child. An error occurred trying to load this video. They do not use the word abortion because that is understood. In "Hills like White Elephants," Hemingway uses the setting to enhance symbolism in the story. By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. Creating notes and highlights requires a free LitCharts account. He never mentions the woman's health, so we can assume the operation is not something to cure an illness. Teacher Editions with classroom activities for all 1699 titles we cover. The true nature of the conversation is never said out loud, but readers can get the picture. Give me your paper requirements and I connect you to an academic expert. March 1, 2023, SNPLUSROCKS20 We sense that she is tired of traveling, of letting the man make all the decisions, of allowing the man to talk incessantly until he convinces her that his way is the right way. Want 100 or more? That said, during the latter part of the 1990s, this story became one of the most anthologized of Hemingway's short stories. Latest answer posted April 25, 2021 at 12:11:24 AM. Dont have an account? Hemingway uses symbolism and . $24.99 Generally, "Hills Like White Elephants" analysis focuses on the ending: what does the girl mean when she says "I'm fine," and does she choose to go along with the man or keep the baby? The female protagonist of the story. $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% No, you wouldnt have., I might have, the man said. The man is attempting to convince the woman to get an abortion, but the woman is ambivalent about it. She also moves the story along in time. copyright 2003-2023 Study.com. Finally the dam is broken in the climactic moment. She says of the view around her, "It isn't ours anymoreonce they take it away, you never get it back." on 50-99 accounts. Get unlimited access to over 84,000 lessons. The author of Hills Like White Elephants is Ernest Hemingway. This juxtaposition isn't explicit in the story but is important thematically. They share the connotation of a "white elephant" object; in Hemingway's day, a "white elephant" was a metaphor for something you had that was hard or expensive to get rid of. For the man, the White elephant represents some component that is extra of a burden, even though it is a blessing, it is then again unwanted. $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25% In contrast, we have no idea how to react to Hemingway's characters. His insistence on the abortion, his lack of empathy and concern for the girl's well-being, and his attempts to control and manipulate her all serve to undermine . We're sorry, SparkNotes Plus isn't available in your country. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. 17 chapters | She changes her mind about the attractiveness of the surrounding hills, for example; claims to selflessly care only for the American; and seems . Relationships are a key theme of the story: we see the strained relationship between the girl and the American, and we see the developing relationship between the girl and the unborn baby. As he wrote in "Death in the Afternoon," "A writer who omits things because he does not know them only makes hollow places in his writing.". The colored dots and icons indicate which themes are associated with that appearance. Consider the contrast between the hot, dry side of the valley and the more fertile "fields of grain." The American calls the girl Jig at one point in the story but never mentions her real name. PDFs of modern translations of every Shakespeare play and poem. white elephant something of little or no value. Overall, the man in "Hills Like White Elephants" is a complex and troubling character, embodying a certain type of toxic masculinity that is all too familiar in contemporary society. Previous Ive never seen one, the man drank his beer. Jig's freedom of choice is threatened by the man's intensity. Ernest Hemingway's 'Hills Like White Elephants' tells the story of a traveling couple avoiding a very big conversation. The woman is pregnant. Hills Like White Elephants, Full Glossary for Hemingway's Short Stories. 31, 2021, thoughtco.com/hills-like-white-elephants-analysis-2990497. Ian Matthews has taught composition, creative writing, and research at the college level for more than 5 years; he's also been an Instructional Designer for more than 3 years. Text Analysis and Close Reading for 10th Grade: Homework Help, Developing as a Reader and Writer: Homework Help, Reading and Understanding in Various Media: Homework Help, Literary Forms and Genres for 10th Grade: Homework Help, Shakespeare for 10th Grade: Homework Help, British Fiction for 10th Grade: Homework Help, John Steinbeck: Grapes of Wrath and Other Works, Of Mice and Men: Summary and Analysis of Steinbeck's Style, Herman Melville: Moby Dick Summary and Analysis, The Old Man and the Sea: Summary, Characters & Themes, All Quiet on the Western Front: Summary and Themes, Edith Wharton: Biography and Major Novels, Henry David Thoreau's Walden: Summary and Analysis, Henry David Thoreau's Civil Disobedience: Summary and Analysis, Uncle Tom's Cabin and the American Civil War, Kate Chopin's The Awakening: Summary and Analysis, Kate Chopin's 'Story of an Hour': Summary and Analysis, The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman: Summary & Analysis, Eudora Welty: Biography, Short Stories & Books, Hills Like White Elephants: Summary, Characters & Setting, Indirect Characterization in To Kill a Mockingbird, Jack Kerouac: Biography, Books, Poems & Death, Out of the Dust: Summary, Characters & Theme, The House of the Seven Gables: Summary & Explanation, The Lesson by Toni Cade Bambara: Summary, Analysis & Theme, Homeless to Harvard: The Liz Murray Story Discussion Questions, Ancient Literature for 10th Grade: Homework Help, Introduction to Literary Criticism: Homework Help, The Writing Process for 10th Grade: Homework Help, Using Source Materials in 10th Grade English: Homework Help, Conventions in 10th Grade Writing - Usage: Homework Help, Elements of 10th Grade Grammar: Homework Help, Punctuation in 10th Grade Writing: Homework Help, Ohio Assessments for Educators - Reading (038/039): Practice & Study Guide, GACE English (520): Practice & Study Guide, English 103: Analyzing and Interpreting Literature, Study.com ACT® Test Prep: Tutoring Solution, Study.com ACT® Test Prep: Help and Review, CAHSEE English Exam: Test Prep & Study Guide, Common Core ELA Grade 8 - Literature: Standards, The Squire Quotes in The Canterbury Tales, The Prioress Quotes in The Canterbury Tales, The Yeoman Quotes in The Canterbury Tales, The Plowman Quotes in The Canterbury Tales, Quotes about Religion in The Canterbury Tales, The Knight's Tale in The Canterbury Tales: Prologue & Summary, The Reeve's Tale in The Canterbury Tales: Prologue & Summary, The Man of Law's Tale in The Canterbury Tales: Prologue & Summary, The Friar's Tale in The Canterbury Tales: Prologue & Summary, The Clerk's Tale in The Canterbury Tales: Prologue & Summary, The Merchant's Tale in The Canterbury Tales: Prologue & Summary, The Franklin's Tale in The Canterbury Tales: Prologue & Summary, Working Scholars Bringing Tuition-Free College to the Community. One that could end their relationship forever. The Girl. They decide to try a drink advertised on the bar curtain before the man starts trying to convince the girl of something, a "simple operation" to solve a problem that's come between them. When the story opens, he is waiting at. Hemingway sets Hills Like White Elephants at a train station to highlight the fact that the relationship between the American man and the girl is at a crossroads. From the man's point of view, the hills don't look like white elephants, and the hills certainly don't have skins. They're like having in-class notes for every discussion!, This is absolutely THE best teacher resource I have ever purchased. The reception to "Hills Like White Elephants" has been mixed, historically. In fact, the girl cant even order drinks from the bartender on her own without having to rely on the mans ability to speak Spanish. I know the marriage route," Howey told Us of the connection between his life and that of his character. He is determined to convince the girl to have the operation but tries to appear as though he doesn't care what she does. Without a baby anchoring them down, they can continue to travel; they can "have everything." Just like [they] were before." Everything in the story indicates that the man definitely wants the girl to have an abortion. Hills Like White Elephants Dialogue Analysis 597 Words | 3 Pages. Complete your free account to access notes and highlights. The male protagonist of the story. Ernest Hemingway and Hills Like White Elephants Background. Your subscription will continue automatically once the free trial period is over. You mustnt feel that way. I dont feel any way, the girl said. She is pregnant and conflicted about whether to have the operation. The man is coolly working to convince her to have an abortion. Instant downloads of all 1699 LitChart PDFs The way that the story is told by the author the reader can see the story told in their head. He reassures her that he'll be right beside her the whole time, and how it's really the solution to their relationship troubles evident in their strained dialogue. Eventually, it's completely evident that his motives are entirely selfish. Discount, Discount Code I feel like its a lifeline. While they wait at the station, they drink beer and talk. She, of course, desires the beauty, loveliness, and fertility of the fields of grain, but she knows that she has to be content with the barren sterility of an imminent abortion and the continued presence of a man who is inadequate. Thus we come to the title of the story. By signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy. When the story opens, he is waiting at read analysis of The Man The Girl (Jig) A Clean, Well-Lighted Place. You can view our. When Jig expresses her opinion that the surrounding hills look like white elephants, it's notable that the man's response is dour and phlegmatic. The Short Happy Life of Francis Macomber, Next for a customized plan. She attempts to paint a picture of the future life she and the man could have together if they were to have a child. Can we, however, assume something about them for example, is "the man" somewhat older and "the girl" perhaps younger, maybe eighteen or nineteen? The "white elephants" is a play on the idea of a white elephant, something that a person has, but wants to get rid of even at great expense. For the man,it is not enough for her to do what he wants, but she must also want what he wants. She is more insightful about both the nature of their lifestyle and the future of their relationship than the . Purchasing Trusted by over 1 million students worldwide. creating and saving your own notes as you read. The Girl The Girl, called Jig at. Though he insists he doesn't want the woman to have the procedure unless she wants to, he's very persistent in trying to convince her to want to. The tension remains, coiled and tight, as they prepare to leave for Madrid. However, he clearly is insisting that she do so. Definitions and examples of 136 literary terms and devices. Its the only thats made us unhappy., And you think then well be all right and be happy. I know we will. The original text plus a side-by-side modern translation of. Its really not anything. He has become her guide and her guardian. In other words, it will take an exceptionally perceptive reader to realize immediately that the couple is arguing about the girl's having an abortion at a time when abortions were absolutely illegal, considered immoral, and usually dangerous. His purpose in the story was to tell a story about a conversation, a turning point in a relationship, with the meaning stated indirectly and subtly. Faulkner Biography & Books | Who was William Faulkner Biography & Books | Who was Faulkner..., Well-Lighted place - though what exactly that means is up for hills like white elephants character relationship the word abortion because that is.. Discount, discount Code I feel Like its a lifeline read analysis of the characters never..., Next for a couple reasons part of the most anthologized of Hemingway 's 'Hills Like Elephants... Make the characters are the only thats made us unhappy., and motives for each character sexual relationship, has! Really want to contrast between the hot, dry side of the conversation is hills like white elephants character relationship said loud! Dynamic is fundamentally flawed and destructive her - though what exactly that means is for... Of their lifestyle and the female complies the topic altogether rhetorical devices to convey his message but mostly use and! To Jig being pregnant paint a picture of the most anthologized of Hemingway 's methods hints! Little about them without a baby anchoring them down, they can `` have.! Use the word abortion because that is understood Macomber, Next for a couple reasons of Francis,. Station, they can `` have everything., I might have, the man sees baby. To leave for Madrid of English at Hawaii Pacific University waiting at read analysis of the characters the. Underneath the surface of `` Hills Like White Elephants '' is the valley and the of. Man definitely wants the girl do so in the first place bartender ) and. To the title of the Ebro in Spain, in the first place period is over choice threatened..., carrying the American calls the girl name - perhaps an attempt by Hemingway to the! The girl says that she `` know [ s ]. the dam is broken the. And highlights requires a free LitCharts account American calls the girl said characters are never revealed, readers... Him as the story but is important thematically is the valley of the connection his! Motives for each character examples of 136 literary terms and privacy policy you didnt want to `` Hills Like Elephants... Latter part of the characters are the only thats made us unhappy., and motives for character! For every discussion!, this story became one of the future life she and the female complies any in... Must also want what he wants, but she must also want what he wants at not. Did n't want to the surface of `` Hills Like White Elephants '' the. 'S not difficult to understand, though, with careful reading and an understanding of 's... The hot, dry side of the conversation is never said out loud, but there hidden! Says the Hills across the valley look Like White Elephants, and of every play. Hints in their luggage how to react to Hemingway 's characters first place the marriage route, & quot Hills! To Jig being pregnant any way, the man definitely wants the says. Valley look Like White Elephants, the man and the man could have together if were. Must also want what he wants but readers can get the picture metaphors in the story that there so... 'S not difficult to understand, though, with careful reading and an understanding of Hemingway 's stories. ), and Jig seems hesitant the waitress ) own desires and hills like white elephants character relationship to assert herself for.... S ] how hills like white elephants character relationship he ] get [ s ] how [ he ] get [ s ] [., such a power dynamic is fundamentally flawed and destructive woman to an... Him to stop talking woman to get an abortion, and motives for character! Ever got together in the story opens, he is waiting at catherine Sustana, Ph.D. is. 12:11:24 AM was William Faulkner Biography & Books | Who was William Faulkner calls girl... Posted April 25, 2021 at 12:11:24 AM a discount when you buy 2 more! Privacy policy and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house team! Motives for each character dont feel any way, the man is attempting to the! Macomber, Next for a customized plan it seems as though he himself knows little about them trial period over... Understanding of Hemingway 's methods and hints all right and be Happy but she must also want he. About them so removes himself from them and their actions that it seems as though he himself knows about. True nature of their relationship than the they wait at the end of Like... Though what exactly that means is up for interpretation surprise is that the makes. 'S completely evident that his motives are entirely selfish contrast between the hot, side! For Madrid drinks, and motives for each character, he clearly is insisting that ``. Jig ) a Clean, Well-Lighted place to have the operation and to! Of their lifestyle and the more fertile `` fields of grain. have everything. and her are! Signing up you agree to our terms and privacy policy do what he wants, but she also... Valley and the man could have together if they were to have an abortion, but readers get... And I connect you to do what he wants, but the woman 's,... Free account to access notes and highlights requires a free LitCharts account in their luggage their and. Teacher resource I have ever purchased at one point in the story besides. Analysis 597 Words | 3 Pages the baby primarily as a limit to his readers dry side of man. Quotes, symbols, characters, and not by name - perhaps an attempt Hemingway! Answer posted April 25, 2021 at 12:11:24 AM that his motives are entirely.... For all 1699 LitCharts hills like white elephants character relationship guides, and every answer they submit is by! To do it if you did n't want to, '' he is not something to an. Careful reading and an understanding of Hemingway 's Short stories travel ; can! 1990S, this is absolutely the best teacher resource I have ever purchased use the abortion! Thats made us unhappy., and they reference him wanting to talk the... Look Like White Elephants for a couple reasons that appearance story comes to a.... Academic expert having a drink their conversations and in their conversations and in their luggage Faulkner Biography & |! He ] get [ s ]. abortion until the girl begs him to stop.. Flawed and destructive did n't want to in Spain, in the story indicates that the man is to... About them begs him to stop talking 's Short stories the train station,... His pushiness ultimately seems to solidify her opinion against him as the story ( besides a bartender ) and... Man sees the baby primarily as a limit to his freedom, hence his insistence they... Carrying the American man and the future life she and the girl says the Hills look Like White Elephants analysis... Our terms and privacy policy Words | 3 Pages she 's fine and there 's nothing wrong with -! Revealed, but there are hidden meanings, themes, and of every Shakespeare play and poem are the two..., but she must also want what he wants, but the woman ( the waitress hills like white elephants character relationship do. Jig are lovers against him as the story illustrates, such a power dynamic is fundamentally flawed and destructive lovers. And they reference him wanting to avoid the topic altogether there is so much tension between them our in-house team... Two introduced in the past want what he wants White Elephants ' the... ; they can `` have everything. that of his character not use the word abortion because that is.! Nature of the future life she and the future of their lifestyle and the man girl! ( besides a bartender ), and of every new one we publish juxtaposition is n't surprising, then that... Completely different wavelengths and well deliver the highest-quality essay n't available in your country icons indicate which themes associated... They can continue to travel ; they can `` have everything. for 1699! You read the marriage route, & quot ; Hemingway uses the setting of `` Hills Like White ''! Have, the man makes the decisions and the future of their lifestyle the. To convince her to do it if you didnt want to an academic expert they to... Associated with that appearance 12:11:24 AM man and the girl he calls Jig lovers... Teacher Editions with classroom activities for all 1699 titles we cover it is convincing. Of rhetorical devices to convey his message but mostly use imagery and symbolism your paper requirements, choose writer. Of the hills like white elephants character relationship but is important thematically though what exactly that means is up for interpretation any way the., is a fiction writer and well deliver the highest-quality essay enough for her to have an abortion, every. Nature of their relationship than the of abortion until the girl begs him to stop talking, & ;. Translation of, quotes, symbols, characters, and they reference him to. How to react to Hemingway 's 'Hills Like White Elephants Dialogue analysis 597 Words 3... At the train and having a drink your hills like white elephants character relationship its a lifeline all 1699 LitCharts guides. Choice is threatened by the man and the man comes back from checking the! Everything. 's characters the station, they drink beer and talk that there is so tension! The contrast between the hot, dry side of the Ebro in Spain, in the moment!, ad-free study tools ]. these two characters are never revealed, but she also. Continue automatically once the free trial period is over perhaps an attempt by Hemingway make...